History of the Trillium Cup Rivalry: 2009

After a 2-0 win at Crew Stadium and a 1-1 draw in Toronto, the Columbus Crew needed a win or draw to clinch the Trillium Cup trophy for the second straight year. Goals from Eddie Gaven and Steven Lenhart brought the Crew to a 2-2 scoreline heading into stoppage time of the final leg. Frankie Hejduk crossed a magnificent ball into the box finding Jason Garey for the header into the back of the net.